Why Bananas on Fishing Boats Bring Bad Luck – Explained

Have you ever heard the superstition that having bananas on board a fishing boat brings bad luck? For decades, fishermen and sailors alike have taken this superstition seriously. Many even refuse to allow bananas on their boats, fearing that they will bring about misfortune.

But where did this superstition come from, and is there any truth to it? In this article, we’ll explore the origins of this strange belief and take a closer look at the scientific explanations behind it. We’ll also examine similar superstitions in other cultures and real-life accounts of bad luck caused by bananas.

So, if you’ve ever wondered why bananas are seen as bad luck on fishing boats, keep reading to find out!

History of the Superstition

The belief that bananas on fishing boats bring bad luck has been around for centuries. The origins of this superstition are unclear, but it’s believed to have originated from ancient mariners who believed that carrying fruits on board would attract insects, which could eat through the ship’s wooden hull.

Another theory suggests that the bad luck associated with bananas on boats comes from the fact that the fruit was often associated with the devil in the past. This association could have led sailors to believe that bringing bananas on board would invite the devil’s presence and bad luck.

Over time, the superstition has become so entrenched that many fishing vessels and their crew members refuse to carry bananas on board, fearing that they will bring misfortune. Some fishermen even go as far as to say that the mere sight of a banana on board can cause a fishing trip to be unproductive or dangerous.

If you’re intrigued by this strange and enduring superstition, keep reading to find out more about the scientific explanations behind it, as well as real-life accounts of the bad luck caused by bananas on fishing boats.

Origins of the Curse

1. Maritime Misfortunes: Some believe that the superstition originated from an old maritime legend. The legend says that boats carrying bananas would often experience unexplainable misfortunes, such as inclement weather or mechanical issues.
2. Trade Wars: Another theory suggests that the superstition began during the early days of the banana trade. Competing companies spread rumors that their rival’s boats were cursed to discourage buyers from purchasing their bananas.
3. Cultural Beliefs: In some cultures, bananas are associated with bad luck or evil spirits. It’s possible that this belief was transferred to the maritime industry and became the basis for the banana superstition.

Regardless of its origins, the superstition has endured for decades and has become a widespread belief among fishermen and sailors.

Infamous Incidents at Sea

Throughout history, there have been many instances where bananas on a fishing boat were believed to have caused bad luck. In one such incident in 1912, a fishing boat named the SS Valbanera sank in the Bermuda Triangle, supposedly due to the presence of bananas on board. All 488 passengers and crew members on board perished.

In another incident in 1968, a boat named the Teignmouth Electron sank while participating in the Sunday Times Golden Globe Race. The sole survivor, Robin Knox-Johnston, had a bunch of bananas on board which he threw overboard, believing they were the cause of the boat’s misfortunes.

These incidents and others like them have contributed to the widespread belief that bananas on a fishing boat are a bad omen.

Scientific Explanations

Microbial Growth: Some researchers believe that bananas on fishing boats could potentially cause the growth of harmful bacteria and fungi that could spoil the catch or even harm the crew. This is because bananas release ethylene gas which accelerates the ripening process of fruits and vegetables, creating an environment ripe for microbial growth.

Self-fulfilling Prophecy: Psychologists suggest that the superstition could be a result of a self-fulfilling prophecy. If a crew believes that bananas are bad luck, they may act more cautiously or superstitiously, leading to a change in behavior that could affect the outcome of their voyage. This, in turn, reinforces the belief in the superstition.

Cultural Transmission: The idea of bananas being bad luck on fishing boats could also be a result of cultural transmission. It is possible that this superstition originated in one culture and then spread to others through cultural exchange, migration, or trade. Over time, it became ingrained in the cultural beliefs of seafarers.

Ethylene Gas and Spoilage

One of the scientific explanations behind the bad luck superstition is related to the ethylene gas produced by ripening bananas. Ethylene is a natural plant hormone that triggers ripening and decay processes in fruits and vegetables. Bananas produce a lot of ethylene gas, which can cause other fruits and vegetables to ripen and spoil faster. On a fishing boat, where preserving fresh catch is crucial, this can lead to lost profits and even hunger.

In addition, ethylene gas can also affect the boat’s equipment, such as the engine, by corroding metal parts and causing malfunctions. This can be especially dangerous in emergency situations, where faulty equipment can put the crew’s lives at risk.

Therefore, it is not surprising that some fishermen avoid bringing bananas on board to prevent the spoilage of other catches and the potential damage to the boat and its equipment.

The Psychological Power of Superstitions

While there may be scientific explanations for the phenomenon of the banana curse, some argue that the power of the superstition lies in our minds. Psychologists have long studied the ways in which beliefs and rituals can impact our perception of luck, control, and probability.

One theory is that superstitions provide a sense of control in situations where we may feel powerless. By adhering to a ritual or belief, we feel as though we are influencing the outcome of an event, even if we have no real control over it. This sense of control can be comforting, especially in high-stress situations such as fishing trips where there are many variables outside of our control.

Another theory is that superstitions can actually improve performance. Research has shown that athletes who engage in superstitious rituals, such as wearing a lucky item of clothing, are more confident and perform better than those who do not. This may be because the ritual helps to reduce anxiety and increase focus, allowing the individual to perform at their best.

The Impact of Confirmation Bias

Confirmation bias is a cognitive phenomenon where people tend to seek out, interpret, and remember information that confirms their preexisting beliefs. It is one of the most pervasive biases that we face in our everyday lives, and it can have a significant impact on how we view the world around us.

Belief perseverance, selective exposure, and group polarization are all ways in which confirmation bias can manifest itself. Belief perseverance is when people hold onto their beliefs even in the face of contradictory evidence. Selective exposure is when people actively seek out information that confirms their beliefs while avoiding information that contradicts them. Group polarization is when people within a group become more extreme in their views because they only hear from others who share those views.

The impact of confirmation bias can be far-reaching. It can affect our personal relationships, our political views, and even our health. For example, people who hold strong anti-vaccination beliefs may selectively expose themselves to information that supports their views while dismissing scientific evidence to the contrary. This can have serious consequences for public health.

• Confirmation bias can lead to misunderstandings and miscommunications.
• It can create an echo chamber where people only hear opinions that they agree with.
• It can cause people to dismiss evidence that contradicts their beliefs.
• Confirmation bias can fuel conspiracy theories and fake news.
• It can make people resistant to change.
• It can hinder personal growth and development.

Recognizing confirmation bias is the first step in overcoming it. By being aware of our biases and actively seeking out diverse perspectives and evidence, we can broaden our understanding of the world and make more informed decisions. It’s important to question our beliefs and challenge ourselves to consider alternative viewpoints.

Impact of Confirmation Bias	Examples	Consequences
Belief perseverance	Refusal to acknowledge climate change despite overwhelming scientific evidence.	Resistance to change and missed opportunities for progress.
Selective exposure	Watching news channels that only align with your political views.	Creates an echo chamber and hinders understanding of opposing views.
Group polarization	Online forums where extreme views become more extreme over time.	Can lead to radicalization and intolerance of opposing views.

Ultimately, the impact of confirmation bias on our lives is profound. By being aware of this bias and actively working to overcome it, we can broaden our perspectives, improve our decision-making, and create a more informed and tolerant society.

Similar Superstitions in Other Cultures

Superstitions have been an integral part of human civilization for centuries. Although the beliefs and practices vary from culture to culture, some superstitions have a surprising degree of similarity. Taboo, magic, and rituals are often found in different cultures, and the reasons behind them are usually similar as well. Here are some examples:

Knocking on Wood: The act of knocking on wood to avoid jinxing something is a common superstition in many cultures. In Japan, it is called knocking on Kichō, which literally means “knocking on good omen.” In Ireland, the superstition is related to fairies, who are believed to live in trees.

Lucky Number Seven: The number seven is considered lucky in many cultures, including African, Chinese, and Indian. In Judaism, the seventh day of the week is the Sabbath, and in Christianity, God rested on the seventh day after creating the world.

Evil Eye: The belief in the evil eye, or the ability of someone to cause harm by looking at them, is common in many cultures. In Greece and Turkey, blue amulets called nazar are worn to protect against the evil eye. In Italy, the horn-shaped cornicello is used for the same purpose.

Friday the 13th: The superstition that Friday the 13th is an unlucky day is found in many cultures. In some Spanish-speaking countries, it is Tuesday the 13th that is considered unlucky. In Italy, the number 13 is considered unlucky, but Friday is not.

Black Cats: In many cultures, black cats are considered a bad omen. In Japan, the superstition is that a black cat crossing your path is bad luck. In the UK, the belief is that a black cat crossing your path from right to left is bad luck, but from left to right is good luck.

These are just a few examples of the many superstitions that are shared across different cultures. Although the origins and practices may differ, the human need for security, hope, and luck remains the same.

Spilling Salt in Russia

In Russia, spilling salt is considered bad luck. This superstition dates back to the time when salt was a precious commodity, and wasting it was a sin. It is also said that Judas Iscariot spilled salt during the Last Supper, and since then, spilling salt has been associated with betrayal and bad luck.

Russians believe that if you spill salt, you have to throw some over your left shoulder to avoid bad luck. It is also believed that if you do not throw the salt over your left shoulder, you may have a fight with someone you love. In some regions of Russia, people believe that if you spill salt, it means that you will have a difficult day ahead.

Interestingly, Russians also believe that if you accidentally spill salt, you can counteract the bad luck by taking a piece of bread and dipping it in the spilled salt. You should then eat the bread, and the bad luck will be reversed. This practice is known as «хлеб с солью» or “bread with salt.”

Whistling on a Theater Stage in the UK

Another popular superstition that has been around for centuries is related to the theater in the United Kingdom. Actors and crew members believe that whistling on a theater stage brings bad luck. This superstition has been passed down from generation to generation, and it’s still very much alive today. If someone whistles backstage, it is believed to bring bad luck and may even cause a performance to fail.

The origins of this superstition are not entirely clear, but one theory suggests that it may be related to the use of whistles during scene changes in the early days of theater. Whistles were used to signal that the scene was about to change, and actors and crew members were not supposed to whistle themselves so as not to cause confusion. Another theory suggests that it may be related to the use of whistling to communicate with spirits in the afterlife.

Whatever the origins, the superstition is still widely believed and respected today. It’s not just limited to the UK, as many theaters around the world also adhere to this belief. Some people go to great lengths to avoid whistling on stage, such as using a bell instead to signal the start of a scene change or mouthing the tune of a song instead of whistling it.

Despite its popularity, there are still those who dismiss the superstition as mere nonsense. They argue that there is no rational explanation for why whistling on stage should be bad luck and that it’s just an old tradition that has been passed down without any real understanding of why it exists.

Regardless of whether you believe in the superstition or not, it’s clear that whistling on a theater stage in the UK is considered a taboo that’s best avoided. If you’re an actor or crew member working in a theater, it’s best to err on the side of caution and avoid whistling at all costs.

Friday the 13th in Western Countries

Friday the 13th is considered an unlucky day in many Western countries, and the superstition has a long history. One theory is that the superstition originated from the Last Supper, where Judas Iscariot, the disciple who betrayed Jesus, was the 13th guest to arrive. Another theory is that the Knights Templar were arrested and executed on Friday the 13th, leading to the belief that it was a day of bad luck.

The superstition surrounding Friday the 13th has led to many people altering their behavior on this day. Some people avoid traveling or making major decisions, while others may refuse to leave their homes or even get out of bed. Some buildings do not have a 13th floor, and some airports do not have a Gate 13.

Despite its long history, there is no evidence to support the belief that Friday the 13th is actually unlucky. In fact, some studies have shown that there are fewer accidents and less traffic on this day, possibly due to the fact that people are more cautious and careful.

Nevertheless, the fear of Friday the 13th, also known as paraskevidekatriaphobia, continues to persist in Western cultures. Some people even seek out ways to ward off bad luck on this day, such as carrying lucky charms or performing rituals.

In some cultures, the number 13 itself is considered unlucky, while Friday is not associated with any negative connotations. In Italy, for example, Friday the 17th is considered unlucky, while in Hispanic and Greek cultures, Tuesday the 13th is the day to watch out for.

Despite the variations in superstitions across cultures, the fear of bad luck and the desire to avoid it is a common human experience. While superstitions can be harmless, they can also have negative consequences when they influence decision-making or reinforce harmful beliefs.

Real-Life Accounts of Bad Luck Caused by Bananas

Belief in the bad luck associated with bananas has been around for centuries. However, many people still experience the ill effects of bananas in real life. For instance, in Japan, a ship carrying bananas sank, and the crew drowned. This incident is still remembered as the “banana shipwreck” and is believed to be a result of the bad luck associated with bananas.

In South Africa, a soccer team blamed their losing streak on bananas that had been thrown onto the pitch by rival fans. They believed that the bananas had cursed them and led to their poor performance.

In another incident in India, a school was closed for a day after a banana tree fell on the premises. The school officials believed that the tree had brought bad luck and that it was best to close the school for the day.

Finally, in the United States, a woman was involved in a car accident after slipping on a banana peel. She believed that the banana peel was a bad omen and had caused the accident.

An Unfortunate Fishing Trip

Jim and his friends had been planning their fishing trip for weeks. They were excited to finally spend the weekend out on the water. As they were packing their gear, Jim’s friend pulled out a bunch of bananas. Jim immediately protested, telling his friend that it was bad luck to bring bananas on a fishing trip. But his friend didn’t believe in superstitions and brought them anyway.

On the first day of fishing, everything seemed to be going well. They caught a few fish and were having a good time. But on the second day, things took a turn for the worse. Jim’s friend accidentally dropped his banana peel into the water, and within minutes, their luck changed. They didn’t catch any more fish and their boat started having engine problems. They ended up having to cut their trip short and go back to shore.

Jim was convinced that the banana was the cause of their bad luck. He later found out that many other fishermen believed in the same superstition. Some even believed that bananas on a boat could cause a storm to come. Jim and his friends never brought bananas on a fishing trip again.

Changing Attitudes Towards the Superstition

Over time, the belief in superstitions has decreased as people have become more educated and scientific in their thinking. Many now view them as mere folklore or cultural traditions, rather than concrete beliefs.

However, some still hold onto these superstitions, often due to personal experiences or cultural upbringing. For example, individuals may avoid walking under ladders or breaking mirrors despite knowing the lack of scientific evidence to support these beliefs.

Modern media has also played a role in shaping attitudes towards superstitions. Movies, TV shows, and books often depict characters who believe in these superstitions and suffer the consequences, leading to a more skeptical attitude towards them.

Despite the decreasing belief in superstitions, they still hold a place in many cultures and continue to be passed down through generations. As society continues to evolve, it is likely that attitudes towards superstitions will also continue to change.

The Rise of Rational Thinking

Science: As science and technology have advanced, many of the superstitions that once held sway over people have been dispelled by evidence-based reasoning. Scientific discoveries have helped us understand the natural world in ways that were once unimaginable, and this has led to a decline in belief in the supernatural.

Education: Another factor in the decline of superstition has been the spread of education. As more people become literate and learn critical thinking skills, they are better equipped to evaluate claims and separate fact from fiction. This has led to a greater skepticism towards superstitions.

Secularism: The rise of secularism, or the separation of religion and state, has also contributed to the decline of superstition. As societies have become more secular, people have turned away from religious beliefs and practices, and this has led to a decrease in belief in the supernatural.

Globalization: Finally, globalization has played a role in the decline of superstition. As people have become more connected through technology and travel, they have been exposed to different cultures and belief systems. This exposure has led to a greater awareness of the diversity of human experience, and this has led to a greater acceptance of different beliefs and practices.

The Persistence of Traditional Beliefs

Despite the rise of science and rational thinking, many people continue to hold onto traditional beliefs and superstitions, often passed down from generation to generation. These beliefs can be deeply ingrained and difficult to shake, even in the face of evidence to the contrary.

One reason for this persistence may be the sense of comfort and control that superstitions can provide. Believing in a lucky charm or ritual can create a sense of security and give people a feeling of control over their lives, even if it is an illusion.

Another factor is the cultural significance of superstitions. Many traditional beliefs are tied to cultural identity and heritage, and letting go of them can feel like abandoning a part of one’s identity.

Additionally, the media and popular culture often perpetuate superstitions and reinforce their importance in certain contexts, such as sports or entertainment. This can further entrench beliefs and make them seem more legitimate.

Ultimately, superstitions are likely to persist as long as humans continue to seek comfort, control, and meaning in the unpredictable and often chaotic world around them.

Conclusion: Should You Believe in the Curse of Bananas on Fishing Boats?

After examining the history and cultural significance of the superstition surrounding bananas on fishing boats, it is clear that belief in the curse is rooted in tradition rather than fact.

While there are certainly cases of bad luck occurring on fishing trips that involved bananas, there is no evidence to suggest that bananas themselves are the cause of these misfortunes.

Ultimately, whether or not to believe in the curse of bananas on fishing boats is a matter of personal belief.

However, it is important to remember that superstitions are often based on irrational fears and beliefs, and it is up to individuals to decide for themselves whether or not to let these beliefs guide their actions.

In the end, it may be more important to focus on safety and best practices when fishing, rather than worrying about the presence of bananas on board.

Frequently Asked Questions